Update: here's the official site of the report.
I am currently listening to ESPN's broadcast of George Mitchell's press conference regarding his report on steroid use in Major League Baseball. Here are a few bullet points mostly paraphrased from Mitchell's conference (which amounted to an executive summary).
- The Report does not violate the basic agreement. This was checked by MLB after it received the report 3 days in advance of today's announcement.
- Steroid use was rampant in baseball.
- Baseball was slow in stopping steroid use, but it has been getting better after clubs and the union adopted a random testing system in 2002.
- Every team has had at least one player that has used.
- Between 5 and 7% tested positive. This proportion is probably underestimated because players knew they would be tested and because of sampling error (Phil: yes, but positive tests can also come with error).
- Players need to be better role models for youngsters. And too many youngsters use steroids, something that should shock Americans. It's partly the fault of MLB players. (Phil: This point extended almost to the point of belaboring).
- Steroid use is unfair to those who don't use them because of positional externalities (my term).
- Some information came from sources who did so "at the request" of government officials (emphasis is mine).
- 11 players admitted Kirk Radomski gave them steroids.
- Brian McNamee saw three players use steroids.
- Players moved towards the use of human growth hormone (not detectable with current urine tests) and water-based steroids (which leave the body quicker than oil-based steroids)
- Some recommendations can be implemented unilaterally by the commissioner. Some can be implemented only after collective bargaining with the MLBPA.
- Prior to 2002, teams did not push hard to stop steroids because of economic fears about the game.
- A goal of this investigation is to bring a close to this chapter in history and to stop future use.
- Most allegations are "distant in time."
- Employers must use rules in place at the time when disciplining employees.
- More than half the players in the report are out of MLB or its "affiliated minor leagues."
- "There is much about performance enhancing drugs in baseball that I did not learn."
- Everyone needs to be involved in the riddance of steroids in baseball.
- Mitchell did his best to uncover the facts.
- The conclusions and recommendations are the most important part of the report, not the naming of names.








Comments